Blogs
Language: barrier or unifier?
East Asia: China, Korea, JapanOne of my favorite parts from the novel is on page 128 when Z is having her birthday party and some friends from her school come. They’re each from a different Asian country; Japan, Korea, and China, and all speak different languages. Z starts to talk about how odd it is that people from these feuding countries can get along. Her friends Yoko and Kim both make very simple, grammatically incorrect statements and Z says “I like that. I like people speak that way. So we understand each other easily.” The fact that they are all in a foreign country trying to learn the same language brings them together, and diminishes any previous allegiance they held with their home countries.
Language first presents Z and the other girls with an obstacle. They are all living in a foreign country where they can barely speak the tongue. Communication becomes muffled and incomprehensible at times, and overwhelmingly frustrating. There is a huge hindrance that they are all trying to climb up, as they become more and more fluent. In this case, language separates them from everyone else in the country. Language is a blockade, and the women are affected negatively by the consequences of not understanding or speaking English. But this is not the only role language plays in their lives.
Each of them may have separate reasons for wanting to learn English, but they all are in the same situation. They understand each others difficulties with adapting to the intimidating situation. Thus, language becomes a means of coalition for all of them. None of them know any of each others native languages, but they are all attempting to achieve the same goal. Language then becomes a tool for unifying them all together. They all understand that even though they may have to keep things on the simplest level as possible, but that they are now able to communicate with each other.


falling into cliche?
I liked this aspect of the novel as well, but reminded me of the kind of cliche that we don't need language to communicate. In my african dance class three girls did a presentation on how they could use dance to communicate beyond language barriers, conveying a similar sentiment. For some reason this cliche seems to bother me, but i suppose things just become cliche after repeatedly displaying their propensity to show the truth.
Language
The end of the book, compared with the endings of many of the others we have read, may seem melodramatic or hung up on sentimentality. From our reading list one wouldn't guess that travel was such a fun or meaningful or joyous thing to do, but this scene rejuvenated a little bit of that for me. I don't know how much of it has to do with her being forced to be there, but it was nice to see our differences being the unifiers of some of our protaganists rather than main characters obsessed with some distant object breaking them down. But i guess that's the point of communication though--a common language trancending all the bianaries and bringing individuals together directly.