Place Studies

Suckerfish

  • Travel Studies
  • Classes
    • Art of Travel
    • Travel Fictions
    • The Travel Habit
    • Archive
  • Studies Abroad
    • Berlin
    • Buenos Aires
    • Florence
    • Ghana
    • London
    • Madrid
    • Paris
    • Prague
    • Shanghai
    • Links & Other Sites
      • Study Abroad Resources
      • Brazil
      • Cuba
      • IHP: Tanzania-Vietnam
      • Venezuela
  • Research
  • A-V
    • A-V materials
    • Place TV
    • Node locations
    • Slideshows
  • Academics
    • Registration
    • Internships
    • Gallatin links
    • NYU Links
  • Life
    • Gallatin events
    • Announcements
    • Events Calendar
    • Places to go
  • News
    • Travel
    • Travel Fictions
    • Travel in the Thirties
    • Travel Classics
    • Travel Literature
    • A Sense of Place
    • Maps
    • NYC
    • Noted New York
    • Noted News
    • Book News
    • Home
    • Search
    • Help
    • Log in

Blogs (Fall 2009)

  • All Blogs
  • Art of Travel
  • Travel Fictions
  • The Travel Habit

Recent Posts

Epiphany in Venice
The Real Lesson is in the Journey
Stranger Danger
The Other Side of the Ocean
Travel Experience and Epiphany

Recent Comments

Would you really want
Packing
I think there may be a logic
I agree with you. I think
i think i actually saw more
Looking back on our arrivals

Blogs

The Pursuit of Happiness

Submitted by alison on Sun, 11/22/2009 - 14:39
  • Travel Fictions
  • Ibn Fattouma
  • Contentment
  • happiness
  • The Journey of Ibn Fattuma

Live HappyLive Happy

The title character of Naguib Mahfouz’s book The Journey of Ibn Fattuma is a man who is on a perpetual search for the utopian society. Unfortunately for him, it is not to be found in the contents of the book. It is left to the readers of the book to decide for themselves if Ibn Fattuma eventually made it to the mythical land of Gebel, but, as in most fictions regarding travel, the destination is overshadowed by the journey. A hero’s quest isn’t about the end result, but the events that led to the conclusion. Ibn Fattuma goes from land to land in order to find a place of enlightenment, but as a result of his travels he comes to a deeper meaning all on his own.

Qindil Muhammad al-Innabi sees a progression of societies and examines their relative merits and shortcomings. He sees a primitive pagan society, a divine right monarchy, a democracy, and a communist culture during the course of his travels, but never feels completely at home in any of them. It is his self-proclaimed mission to find a society that he can use to remodel the values of his homeland. He is unsuccessful in this quest because he never finds a place that he prefers. He lives his life with the hope that he will eventually find something better somewhere else in the world but just can’t seem to find it.

I think that far too many travelers go in search of that “something better” just to find disappointment. This is especially common in our modern world where the media is constantly projecting the message that traveling is the only way to find happiness. People are often presented in the media as unhappy in their day-to-day lives, further perpetuating the idea that the average person is unhappy. Our society tells us that we are unhappy and we believe it. Maybe, if the media didn’t tell us that we are so miserable, we would be happier.

Qindil discovers along the way to Gebel the enlightenment he thinks he will find there. He learned to accept life as it happened to him and to be fine with the results. His acceptance of himself is the kind of higher meaning he was searching for, and by so doing, he created his own perfect reality. It just goes to show that anyone can be happy as long as they set their mind to it. Happiness can seem elusive sometimes, but that could simply be yet another propagandist idea from a culture that creates discontent in order to sell products. By rejecting these ideas, one can learn to be happy at home, without a lifetime of searching. I don’t think that Gebel is necessarily a physical place as much as it is a state of mind.

  • alison's blog

Something Better

Submitted by Stacy Wynn on Tue, 11/24/2009 - 10:24.

I completely agree with most of you analyses of the novel. I think that your discussion about the search for “something better” is so true in today’s modern society. When traveling in search of something better it seems that the traveler always has expectations that are too high thus, he can never truly find happiness. In most of the cases we have studied in class it seems as if these travelers who yearn for something more are never quite content with what they find. Perhaps these travelers should look to their own lives for that “something better” and stop running away from their problems in search of a better and happier life. In the case of Ibn Fattouma I think his search is nobler and not as self-serving. He is searching for “something better” in order to enhance the lives of those who dwell in his homeland. This search is never quite complete but the journey does educate and enlighten Ibn Fattouma in many ways.

Gebel

Submitted by babelfish on Tue, 11/24/2009 - 03:44.

I don't know if Qindil really just accepts what's happening to him through peace of mind rather than through the fact that he really has no other options, but I do agree that Gebel could definitely be a state of mind rather than an actual "land".  Even at the end of the book though, I don't think Qindil is close enough to finding his own mental utopia.  He's still a man unsure of what he's truly looking for, so I'd probably assume that he would have to spend more years country hopping before he realizes that Gebel is what you make of it in your mind.

Contact * About Place Studies * RSS

Powered by Drupal * Site Map * Course Archive

User Agreement * Privacy * Comment Policy

Copyright © 2008 PlaceStudies.com


RoopleTheme