Place Studies

Suckerfish

  • Travel Studies
  • Classes
    • Art of Travel
    • Travel Fictions
    • The Travel Habit
    • Archive
  • Studies Abroad
    • Berlin
    • Buenos Aires
    • Florence
    • Ghana
    • London
    • Madrid
    • Paris
    • Prague
    • Shanghai
    • Links & Other Sites
      • Study Abroad Resources
      • Brazil
      • Cuba
      • IHP: Tanzania-Vietnam
      • Venezuela
  • Research
  • A-V
    • A-V materials
    • Place TV
    • Node locations
    • Slideshows
  • Academics
    • Registration
    • Internships
    • Gallatin links
    • NYU Links
  • Life
    • Gallatin events
    • Announcements
    • Events Calendar
    • Places to go
  • News
    • Travel
    • Travel Fictions
    • Travel in the Thirties
    • Travel Classics
    • Travel Literature
    • A Sense of Place
    • Maps
    • NYC
    • Noted New York
    • Noted News
    • Book News
    • Home
    • Search
    • Help
    • Log in

Blogs (Fall 2009)

  • All Blogs
  • Art of Travel
  • Travel Fictions
  • The Travel Habit

Recent Posts

Epiphany in Venice
The Real Lesson is in the Journey
Stranger Danger
The Other Side of the Ocean
Travel Experience and Epiphany

Recent Comments

Would you really want
Packing
I think there may be a logic
I agree with you. I think
i think i actually saw more
Looking back on our arrivals

Blogs

Something Completely Different

Submitted by alison on Fri, 12/04/2009 - 00:26
  • Travel Fictions
  • Sputnik Sweetheart

Elementary School Children in UniformElementary School Children in Uniform

 

I realize that there are dozens of topics related to traveling that I could write about in this post (ranging from the physical to the metaphysical), but what I found most interesting was the culture that K experiences at home in Japan. K is a native to Japan, so he overlooks aspects of his culture that mystified me at first. To be more specific, I am referring to the scene in which his married lover calls him to a supermarket to help her out of a sticky situation. I was horrified when he entered the security room to discover not only the lover, but her son as well. I thought that everyone would assume that the two were having an affair, because that is what I would have assumed. I was even more perplexed when none of the characters saw the oddity of the situation in the slightest. Why didn’t anyone else think it was weird that a teacher was called to a store to discuss a student’s shoplifting? Didn’t anyone find it odd that the mother called his teacher for help instead of her husband? How was it any of his business?

With a bit of research, I discovered that it is not uncommon in Japan for teachers to intervene in disciplinary actions outside of the classroom. Teachers are, according to a website on Japanese school culture, “particularly concerned about developing the holistic child” and even monitor their students’ “personal hygiene, nutrition, and sleep”. It is the Japanese belief that a whole village should be involved in the raising of a child, a belief that stems from the society’s group-conscious culture. Each Japanese citizen takes it upon himself to teach morals to a misbehaving child. For example, it is customary for each school to have a different uniform, not to promote school pride, but instead for easy identification in case a student is caught misbehaving. In the event that a child decides to skip school, ordinary people will take it upon themselves to notify the school of the infraction. The Japanese take child rearing very seriously and personally, so it wasn’t unusual for a teacher to be called in to punish a child after an incident like shoplifting.

This seems bizarre to me, but it broaches an interesting topic involving cultural differences and the traveler: how bizarre is my culture? Are there aspects of my own life that I accept as normal, but might be construed by a visitor to be peculiar? I could probably list off a hundred things that might seem odd to foreigners, but I feel as if that topic was adequately addressed in A Concise Chinese-English Dictionary. I will, however, say that I think societal differences are my own personal reason for traveling. I find it refreshing to see other cultures, note differences, and consider how an outsider might view my world. I feel as if I am not so much alienated from my own culture as simply curious about the cultures of others. Maybe I’m not as deep as the people we have read about this past semester, but I could just be more content with my life. And that is something I think a lot of people never get. People can spend so much time searching for the elusive “good life” that they forget to spend time appreciating what they already have. As a general rule, I never want to become blasé about my own culture; it’s a lot more fun to look at ordinary things and see the extraordinary than it is to see nothing at all.

Location

  • alison's blog

education-wise

Submitted by babelfish on Tue, 12/08/2009 - 01:36.

The thing about the role of teachers in Asia in general is that they're less focused on being limited to the setting of a classroom and more focused on being a mentor to the students they're teaching.  It's not uncommon in Asian countries for students to visit the teacher's homes in groups from class.  My grandfather was a high school English teacher in Taiwan and at his funeral we still got a lot of ... wreaths and flower arrangements from students that had heard of his passing.  I'm fairly certain that the tension regarding the possible unearthing of the affair was intentional, but the fact that a teacher was brought in to discipline a student even outside of school isn't really out of bounds.  Sputnik Sweetheart was originally published in Japanese and was later translated into English, so I don't think the whole situation was meant to trouble the readers who originally would've easily understood the role of a teacher in society.

As was previously mentioned,

Submitted by B. on Mon, 12/07/2009 - 20:16.

As was previously mentioned, I was convinced that the security guard knew, and that was why he had that whole speech, " One last thing... Since I laid eyes on you there's something just not quite right..." That whole time I was convinced that the security guard was going to guess what it was and that "K" was going to be in trouble. I also thought that a teacher becoming so involved in the private life of a student was off, but no character objected.

 

I think it's something interesting that we can take away, whether I agree with it or not, it almost shows Murakami's view toward education as well. It is a matter that is to be taken seriously, and made a part of every facet of daily life.

Strange for One, Typical for Others

Submitted by Stacy Wynn on Mon, 12/07/2009 - 11:04.

I agree with you recognition of the oddity of the scene at the supermarket between K, his lover, and her son. As I was reading the novel, I was also a bit confused as to why the mother felt it was necessary to involve the boy’s teacher in a non-academic situation. After reading your research, it doesn’t seem as if this was that strange in Japanese culture but to me, as an American, I still find it to be a little far from my norm.

I think that it is interesting to look at different cultures through an academic lens. Every culture views schooling in a different way and by looking at these practices, one can learn a lot about different societies. I think that this take on the novel was smart and thought provoking. From your research I gather that this scene, which seemed so peculiar to us, was actually typical in Japanese culture. I wonder if Murakami intended for us to see this as strange thus forcing his reader to do some research and begin to understand different customs in different cultures.

 

Contact * About Place Studies * RSS

Powered by Drupal * Site Map * Course Archive

User Agreement * Privacy * Comment Policy

Copyright © 2008 PlaceStudies.com


RoopleTheme